|

|
|
|
|
|
| |
Let's Go
Learn receives a tremendous number of questions by
concerned parents. As a result, we are posting the
answers to the most frequently asked questions in this
section. You may also want to visit our partner,
Homeschool.com, where our very own Amy Pedigo is a
guest advisor: Homeschool.com's
Reading Advisor section.
|
|
Q:
My son seems to mix up the sounds he sees and hears...
Q: My child is 4 years old and doesn't seem
very interested in books...
Q: My son is in 2nd grade and can read OK but
can't spell very well...
Q: My daughter is in seventh grade and
reading and spelling have always been hard for her...
Q: My son is in 3rd grade and does not like
reading. He never wants to read...
Q: If my child scores poorly on a reading
assessment does that mean my child is dyslexic?
Q: My daughter's teacher told me that she
thinks my daughter has poor phonemic awareness. ..
Q: My daughter is in fourth grade. She is not
a very good speller. The weird thing is, she seems to spell the
words wrong differently every time...
Q: My son can read very well. He reads the
words but doesn't seem to understand them...
Q: My child is struggling with reading in
school. I keep hearing about these commercially - available phonics
programs and how they can help kids read better. Which one is best?
Q: My child is a fourth grader, and his
teacher told me in a conference the other day that he couldn't read.
How can I help him catch up?
Q: I'm trying to get my child interested in
reading. I've bought her all the books I loved as a kid, plus new
stories I think would engage her. Unfortunately, she says these
books are boring...
Q: My fifth - grader is doing poorly in his
history class. His teacher says it's because he can't do the
reading...
Q: When my son reads out loud, he skips
words and adds words that are not written in the text...
Q: Is it "normal" for my 2nd grade
daughter to spell words with many missing letters?
Q: My daughter seems to read aloud with
great voice inflection, accuracy and expression. However, she
doesn't seem to understanding what she is reading...
Q: Is it helpful to read aloud to my child
every night?
Q: My daughter doesn't seem to read as well
as some of her classmates...
Q:
My son seems to mix up the sounds he sees and hears. Sometimes he
sounds words out with the right sounds and then says the wrong word.
Once he read the word "stump." He said each one of the
sounds, sounding it out. Then when I prompted him to put it all
together, he said, "stank." Why does he do that?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): The trouble you are describing sounds like weak
phonemic awareness. Phonemic awareness is the ability to distinguish
one sound from another in a word. A reader with fully developed
phonemic awareness can think about the separate sounds in the word
as well as the sounds blended together. Readers with weak phonemic
awareness will have trouble sounding out words correctly and will
sometimes have a hard time pronouncing difficult words. However,
"phonemic awareness" has become a very trendy term in the
reading world so people are starting to use it as a blanket term for
reading troubles. Labels are less important than the symptoms he may
be experiencing. You may wish to have him assessed so that you can
determine his exact strengths and weakness in reading. Regardless of
the label for the troubles he is experiencing, he is having a hard
time sounding out words and needs support in that area.
Q:
My child is 4 years old and doesn't seem very interested in books.
Does that mean he won't be a good reader? Should I have him
assessed?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Your son is too young to be assessed with a
reading assessment. He is also too young for anyone to determine if
he will be a good reader. (Some professionals disagree with me but I
have seen too many young children forced into reading too young. A
wonderful and wise speech pathologist that I used to work with said
that a child who is ready to begin learning to read will show an
interest in letters and sounds. "Don't ask the child to say the
sound or to repeat after you. Say the sounds yourself and when the
child is ready, he or she will start repeating after you.")
However, a child with an aversion to books, especially the child who
doesn't like being read to may have some reading and or learning
difficulties in the future, or not. At four years old, it's just too
early to tell. Reading to your child is your best bet for now.
Reading aloud to your children is important on many levels. The
conversations we have in our every day lives are just not as
sophisticated as the language used in some books. Reading aloud to
your child may by the only way for your child to be exposed to more
advanced language. In addition, by your own enjoyment of reading you
are modeling good reading habits for your child. You should monitor
your son for the next year and pay close attention to how well he
learns his letters and sounds in Kindergarten. Chances are, he will
be fine.
Q:
My son is in 2nd grade and can read OK but can't spell very well.
Should I have him assessed?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Yes. The processing abilities that are required to
make a good speller are the some of the same processing abilities
that make a good reader. Beginning readers who have trouble spelling
often have trouble becoming efficient readers as well. In my
experience, adults who consider themselves poor spellers are often
phonetic spellers. Take a look at the spelling mistakes that your
son is making. Do his mistakes seem to spell out the sounds of the
word? (kuk for cook, hoo for who, nite for nigh, joos for juice etc)
This would indicate that he is trying to spell phonetically. If your
son is making this kind of mistake, he is on the right track. He is
putting the sounds of the words in order, a task some readers find
very difficult. This kind of child may need a bit of support to
learn the actual spelling of the words. Or does it seem that his
spelling mistakes don't follow the sounds of the word at all? (sgt
for sight, chrp for truck, ement for equipment, cshus for curious
etc) Your son may be making one or both of these types of mistakes.
Q:
My daughter is in seventh grade and reading and spelling have always
been hard for her. Reading and spelling were always hard for me too
and I still don't like reading very much. Should she be assessed or
can we both be assessed?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Yes, she or both of you can be assessed. However,
reading and spelling are not going to get easier for a seventh
grader with out some intervention. (Instruction in reading is part
of a school's curriculum through the fourth grade in most states)
The first step to intervention is assessment. It will be important
to know what her reading strengths and weaknesses are. If she has
coped thus far, she is probably strong in some areas and weak in
others. As high school and then college approach, she will be
expected to complete larger and larger quantities of reading and
writing. She may be able to get by but she may feel like there is
not enough time in the day to do all the work required. Getting help
now will be more effective than later. As for you, adults from every
walk of life have difficulty with reading. Studies show that 20-30%
of the world's population has weakness in the processing abilities
necessary for reading. You may want to think about taking an online
assessment; this can give you or anyone the dignity and privacy they
may desire. Or you can go a different route and have your daughter
and or yourself assessed by a local professional who can explain
everything to you if you are not comfortable reading a report that
would be generated by an online assessment. If you are interested in
improving your own reading level, go for it by all means. I
personally have worked with business men, construction workers,
moms, grad students and even a few people in their seventies. It is
never too late.
Q:
My son is in 3rd grade and does not like reading. He never wants to
read and is not interested in books. Does that mean he is not a very
good reader?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Not necessarily. If he is doing fine with reading
and spelling in school, he may be fine. However, he may not like
reading because it is hard for him. Most anyone likes doing things
that come easily. Third grade is a particularly critical time where
reading is concerned. Third grade is the first time a student is
required to read independently. A lot of readers realize reading
problems for the very first time in midyear of third grade. Monitor
his progress closely to make sure that he continues to make
appropriate progress. Identifying a reading issue early is one of
the most important things your can do for your child's reading
abilities. A child who is one year behind this year will likely by
two years behind next year and so on.
Q:
If my child scores poorly on a reading assessment does that mean my
child is dyslexic?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): No. The term "dyslexia" has become a
catch-all term for any kind of reading trouble. If you look at the
National Institutes of Health manual of all diagnosable diseases,
dyslexia is described as a significant gap between your potential
and your performance in reading. Dyslexia can only be diagnosed by a
full psycho-educational evaluation. Sometimes the "label"
for the problem is less important than the symptoms. If your child
is having trouble with reading, find out what his specific strengths
and weakness are and help him develop his relatively weak areas.
Dyslexia or not, he will need to improve his weaknesses in reading.
Q:
My daughter's teacher told me that she thinks my daughter has poor
phonemic awareness. Does that mean she won't be a good reader?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Not necessarily. Poor phonemic awareness is an
indicator of reading difficulties. Phonemic awareness is the ability
to distinguish one sound from another in a word. A reader with good
phonemic awareness can think about the separate sounds in the word
as well as the sounds blended together. Readers with poor phonemic
awareness will have trouble sounding out words correctly and will
sometimes have a hard time pronouncing difficult words. However,
"phonemic awareness" has become a very trendy term in the
reading world so people are starting to use it as a blanket term for
reading troubles. Have your daughter assessed to determine her exact
strengths and weakness with reading. Whether or not she has a
weakness where phonemic awareness is concerned, if she has trouble
reading, she should receive help. Treating the symptoms is sometimes
much more important than figuring out the label of the problem.
Q:
My daughter is in fourth grade. She is not a very good speller. The
weird thing is, she seems to spell the words wrong differently every
time. She spelled "straight" several different ways in the
same paragraph. Why does she do that?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Sometimes these kinds of spelling mistakes are
made because the speller has a hard time making a mental image of
letters. This difficulty will make spelling very hard. Good spellers
have the ability to picture a word in the mind's eye. After the
speller is exposed to the word a few times, the speller can hold
onto the image. However, this task is very difficult for some
people. It is some times called "symbol imagery weakness."
This same weakness may make memorizing words for reading difficult
too. But aside from all that, knowing your daughter's specific
strengths and weaknesses in this area will be important. The first
step to any problem like this is assessment. Having your daughter
assessed by a reading professional will be very helpful for you.
Several of the same learning processes involved with spelling, are
essential to reading. It sounds as if she has some strengths with
spelling if she is able to think of several ways to spell words.
Determining the gap between her strengths and weaknesses will help
you to make the most informed decisions about instruction.
Q:
My son can read very well. He reads the words but doesn't seem to
understand them. He just can't seem to remember what the story was
about. Some times he can't remember even after he rereads the story.
Is this a reading problem?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): It can be. It sounds like your son is doing quite
well in the area of letter sound relationships, so there's a lot to
build on. If your son can read the words fine but cannot understand
and/or remember the story, he probably has some of the same troubles
with oral language. He may not remember oral directions, may not
remember what happened in a movie or may have a hard time following
a complex conversation. This kind of problem is sometimes classified
as a "reading comprehension" problem, but it should really
be called a "language comprehension" problem, since the
difficulty probably isn't specific to just reading. On the other
hand, some children put so much cognitive energy into "sounding
right" when they read that they don't focus on meaning. I have
observed this most often when the student is reading aloud to an
adult. Think about when you have to read a passage that has very
difficult words in it, words that you don't use often. (Like an
engine manual for a tractor) By concentrating on sounding out these
unfamiliar words, you may not be attending to the concept of the
passage. Try to observe your child to see if he has the same kind of
difficulties understanding and remembering oral conversation. If he
does, it may be a language comprehension weakness. If he doesn't, it
may be a reading weakness. Either way, having him assessed to
determine his exact reading strategies is probably your best bet.
Q:
My child is struggling with reading in school. I keep hearing about
these commercially - available phonics programs and how they can
help kids read better. Which one is best?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Before you ask which phonics program is best for
your child, ask whether or not the root of your child's reading
difficulty's phonics. True, many struggling readers need to firm up
their knowledge of relationships between letters and letter -
patterns and the sounds they represent. But there are other sources
of reading difficulty: New, or "emergent" readers, must
master the "concepts of print" -- for example, reading
left - to - right; return sweep, the concepts of a word and of a
sentence; punctuation and so forth. Vocabulary and other knowledge
the reader brings to reading also influence the reading process, as
does a reader's familiarity with grammar and sentence structure.
Experienced readers use all of this information - without even
thinking about it - to successfully read for meaning, whereas
struggling readers, as often as not, have difficulties in varying
degrees in more than one of these areas. What's more, other factors
can play a role in a student's success with reading in school, such
as his or her attitudes and previous experiences with reading. So,
to get back to your question, is a phonics program the answer?
Perhaps. But the only way of knowing is to have your child take a
comprehensive reading assessment such as that developed by Let's Go
Learn.
Q:
My child is a fourth grader, and his teacher told me in a conference
the other day that he couldn't read. How can I help him catch up?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Popular perceptions notwithstanding, rare indeed
is the child who "can't read" by fourth grade. While many
fourth - graders certainly struggle with fourth-grade level reading
material; they still may know a very great deal about reading. For
example, they might be aware that print carries meaning; they might
know the letters of the alphabet and many of the sounds those
represent; they might know where on a page one begins reading and
who to move from line to line; they might have a sizeable store of
words they know by sight. The point here is that to help a child
develop improve his or her reading abilities, you have to discover
where the child is in the development of his or her reading skills
and strategies. This requires a comprehensive, individualized
reading assessment. Unfortunately, many schools lack the resources
to implement such an assessment.
Q:
I'm trying to get my child interested in reading. I've bought her
all the books I loved as a kid, plus new stories I think would
engage her. Unfortunately, she says these books are boring. How can
I hook my daughter on reading?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Modeling your own love of reading is one of the
most important things you can do to encourage your child to become a
reader in his or her own right. Sharing the books you loved is a
child can be an important part of that process. You may also want to
consider other approaches. Start with your child's interests: Just
what does he or she enjoy doing? What subject or topic holds
particular fascination for him or her? Include your child in the
selection of his or her own reading material when you visit the
library or bookstore. You may find that expository books on
particular topics - cars, pop-stars, music, dinosaurs, etc. - might
be more of a "hook" that stories. That's fine! The
important thing is that your child engages in the reading process.
A
second thing you might want to consider is the reading level of the
particular books you and your child select. Children can easily
become frustrated by books which too difficult for their current
reading skills (often they express this by dismissing a particular
book as "boring"). Knowing this, some parents look for the
"reading level" often found on the back or inside covers
of children's books to match them with their child's grade level.
However, that information tells you the book's level - not that of
your child's. It is important to find your child's own reading
level, which may or may not correspond to his or her grade level. A
comprehensive reading assessment, such as that provided by Let's Go
Learn, can provide this necessary information.
Q:
My fifth - grader is doing poorly in his history class. His teacher
says it's because he can't do the reading. But when I have him read
his textbook, he has no difficulty at all. What do you think the
problem might be?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): There are any number of possible reasons why a
child may have difficulties in a particular subject. In your child's
case, his history teacher feels that the root problem has something
to do with reading. Without knowing more about the situation, it's
hard to say if the problem lies in the amount of reading, the
interest the material has for your child, the strategies your child
brings to history - text reading, or some other factor. You mention
that when you have your child read his textbook to you, he has no
apparent difficulty. If you mean that he's able to read it smoothly,
without "stumbling," the problem might lie in
comprehension. Sometimes students put so much cognitive energy into
"sounding right" when the read that they are not actually
attending to the meaning of the text. History textbooks contain
features that can be challenging to children who are more familiar
with narrative text: tables, graphs, headings, timelines and so
forth ....
Q:
When my son reads out loud, he skips words and adds words that are
not written in the text. Does my son have a reading problem?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Not necessarily. Check to see if what your son is
saying makes sense grammatically or makes sense in the context of
the story that he's reading. Like adults, children often omit and
add words in a story to make it sound like what they're expecting to
hear. However, adults often catch their mistake when they notice
that what they said did not match what was written in the text. When
your son does add or omit words what makes sense in the story,
reinforce the strategy that he's using, but also prompt him with a
phrase like, "did what you say match?"
Q:
Is "normal" for my 2nd grade daughter to spell words with
many missing letters?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): It depends on what type of letters is missing. By
second grade, children should have good control of the sounds they
hear in words and how they are represented by a letter or letter
patterns. If your daughter's spelling attempts of words are
"phonetically" correctly (i.e., all the letters
appropriately match a specific sound) your daughter is still learn
may still be learning the conventions of irregular words or words
that she doesn't encounter often. These conventions are still
working its way to her long-term memory. It's natural for second
graders to still be learning these conventions. However, if your
daughter is missing letters to many sounds that are in words, she
may need intervention in accelerating her attention to the discrete
sounds in words (or phonemes).
Q:
My daughter seems to read aloud with great voice inflection,
accuracy and expression. However, she doesn't seem to understanding
what she is reading, what can I do to help her?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Do a lot of discussion about what she is reading.
Before she reads aloud to you, talk about the book before you read
together and get her ready to seek out information about the story
as she reads. Model for her what good readers do when they are
trying to make sense of what they read. That is explaining what runs
through your head when you read. Ask the same questions that you
would subconsciously ask while you're reading the same text. Discuss
the events of the story as you together. You can even stop her
occasionally and ask her what she is thinking after she reads a
small section. Also, try asking her to read silently, section by
section (paragraph or page) and describe what she read, have her
draw a picture and explain her thoughts and feelings about the story
while you help her make connections to what she knows. Sometimes
children are exerting so much energy to sound "good" while
they read aloud that they are not construction meaning from the
text. That's why it may be a good idea to include some silent guided
reading while you read together.
Q:
Is it helpful to read aloud to my child every night?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): Every exposure to reading and literacy-related
activities is always helpful. However, this does not always foster
the independence in using good reading strategies and behaviors. You
can make reading aloud to your child a more meaningful experience by
modifying your nightly read-alouds. For comprehension, talk about
the story as you read it with your child. Ask meaningful "What
do you think?," "How do you suppose?," or "Why
do you think?," types of questions. Try to stray away from
factual questions. To practice oral reading, take turns reading
pages or paragraphs aloud. Or, when you use text with lots of
dialogue, have your child take the voice of one character while you
take the voice of the other character. Not matter what you decide to
do; making your nightly read-alouds more interactive will make it a
more meaningful learning experience for you child.
Q:
My daughter doesn't seem to read as well as some of her classmates.
When is it appropriate for my child to be assessed for her reading?
A:
(Let's Go Learn): School age children's reading abilities can be
assessed anytime. It's always a good idea to have a good idea of
what your child's strengths and weaknesses are in reading. Although
you may think that your child may not read as well as her
classmates, but after a thorough diagnostic assessment, you'll have
a better idea of you child's strengths in reading and will be able
to address the particular needs of your child, regardless of the her
classmates.
|